Revenue Agenda
  • Investing
  • Latest News
  • Editor’s Pick
  • Economy
  • Investing
  • Latest News
  • Editor’s Pick
  • Economy
No Result
View All Result
Revenue Agenda
No Result
View All Result
Home Investing

Who are the Americans who support secession?

by
September 22, 2023
in Investing
0
Who are the Americans who support secession?
0
SHARES
4
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) reached the point of diminishing returns some time ago. One can only repeat fringe rhetoric so many times before it loses its shock value, before it just becomes the sort of thing you’re expected to say.

So when she argued on Sept. 11 — Patriot Day, as some have it — that states should consider secession, it attracted much less attention than similar outbursts she’s offered in the past. But it’s worth considering Greene’s comments less for her argument than for what it doesn’t capture well: the reasons that about 1 in 5 Americans support the concept of secession.

For the representative from Georgia, the putative rationale for secession was the border. President Biden’s policies, she claimed, included a refusal “to stop the invasion of cartel led human and drug trafficking into our country” which meant that “states should consider seceding from the union.” This is not a well-honed argument, of course; it’s ostensibly an effort to cast Biden as negligent and dangerous.

Nor does it seem that frustration with the federal government is necessarily what motivates support for secession. Instead, new research from Colby College assistant professor Nicholas F. Jacobs argues that an important factor in support for secession is the division between states.

“Partisan intensity does not do much explanation” in existing support for secession, Jacobs explained in an email. “Rather, it is highly dependent (almost entirely) on whether or not someone really thinks that red and blue states are just different — and different on meaningful dimensions, such as quality of government services, etc.”

And that, he argues, is the threat to confidence in our existing system.

“When political divisions take on a territorial dimension,” he writes in the paper (“Seeing Red and Blue”), “foundational attitudes central to maintaining the delicate federal relationship are challenged.

“No longer one country seeking to accommodate diverse peoples, some individuals see many peoples fitting uneasily into one federation, threatening collective decision-making,” he continues. “In the United States, between 20 and 30 percent of Democratic and Republican partisans are willing to express some agreement with secessionist sentiments, even in the absence of a major secessionist party or movement.”

As part of his research, he asked respondents to evaluate a number of political questions, including three that addressed secession. About 18 percent of respondents agreed with all three proposals, including having states with opposing politics leave the union, having their own state do so or simply agreeing that some division of the country made sense.

But again, this sentiment overlapped with the perception that there is a bifurcation between types of states. “[T]hose favoring secession are the least likely to tolerate partisan differences between the states,” he writes, “while at the same time, [they] are the most likely to see state-level political divides.”

Soon after Jacobs and I had communicated about his research, Pew Research Center released a new analysis of America’s political divisions. Included in its analysis was a measure that seemed salient to Jacobs’s observation: Most Americans are very or extremely concerned that a person’s rights might be different based on the state they are in, including nearly three-quarters of Democrats.

There’s been a big jump in that belief since 2022, certainly in large part because of the shift in the access to abortion. But this suggests an increase in the extent to which Democrats, in particular, view states’ governance as often dissimilar, the view that correlates to more acceptance of secession.

Jacobs was quick to point out, in his paper and in our discussion, that he is not suggesting that violence will follow. America’s experience with calls for secession was, of course, intermingled with horrific violence and a subsequent slow recovery. But he also indicated that he wasn’t sure how this sense that two countries are emerging might be countered.

“[A] substantial contingent of both major parties view themselves as ‘vulnerable’ to the other party,” he explained. That sense of vulnerability might be ameliorated by empowering more state-level decision-making — but that would then heighten the extent of the perceived divide between states.

“To the extent that this is what drives support for secession,” he said, “it seems like in our highly nationalized and polarized political climate, further decentralization is just as problematic as greater centralization.”

And then there’s the other problem: States are not themselves homogenous.

“[N]o matter what [Marjorie Taylor Greene] wants,” he said, “secession won’t offer that salve in the U.S. since the divide exists within states as much as it does between them.”

As good a reason to avoid secession as any.

This post appeared first on The Washington Post
Previous Post

DeSantis is in growing trouble. He’s betting big on Iowa to rescue him.

Next Post

Former DOJ attorney acted with Trump’s approval, his lawyer says

Next Post
Former DOJ attorney acted with Trump’s approval, his lawyer says

Former DOJ attorney acted with Trump’s approval, his lawyer says

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Top 10 Potash Countries by Production (Updated 2024)

Top 10 Potash Countries by Production (Updated 2024)

August 21, 2024
Top 10 Phosphate Countries by Production (Updated 2024)

Top 10 Phosphate Countries by Production (Updated 2024)

August 1, 2024
Top 10 Uranium-producing Countries (Updated 2024)

Top 10 Uranium-producing Countries (Updated 2024)

November 6, 2024
7 Biggest Lithium-mining Companies in 2024

7 Biggest Lithium-mining Companies in 2024

September 18, 2024
Triumph Gold’s Executive Chairman Discusses Utah Silver-Gold Acquisition and Exploration Strategy in New INN CEO Insights Interview

Triumph Gold’s Executive Chairman Discusses Utah Silver-Gold Acquisition and Exploration Strategy in New INN CEO Insights Interview

0
New Hampshire Gov. Sununu signs $15.2B ‘miracle’ budget into law

New Hampshire Gov. Sununu signs $15.2B ‘miracle’ budget into law

0

Pennsylvania House clears tax credits for new teachers, nurses, police officers

0
Evers signs bipartisan sales tax bill aimed at sparing Milwaukee from bankruptcy

Evers signs bipartisan sales tax bill aimed at sparing Milwaukee from bankruptcy

0
Triumph Gold’s Executive Chairman Discusses Utah Silver-Gold Acquisition and Exploration Strategy in New INN CEO Insights Interview

Triumph Gold’s Executive Chairman Discusses Utah Silver-Gold Acquisition and Exploration Strategy in New INN CEO Insights Interview

July 9, 2025
Quimbaya Gold

Quimbaya Gold

July 9, 2025
Juggernaut Closes $1,100,000 from Institutions and Accredited Investors

Juggernaut Closes $1,100,000 from Institutions and Accredited Investors

July 9, 2025
High Grade Cu-Au at Surface Delivers New Targets at Mankayan

High Grade Cu-Au at Surface Delivers New Targets at Mankayan

July 9, 2025
Enter Your Information Below To Receive Trading Ideas and Latest News

Error: Contact form not found.

Your information is secure and your privacy is protected. By opting in you agree to receive emails from us. Remember that you can opt-out any time, we hate spam too!

Recent News

Triumph Gold’s Executive Chairman Discusses Utah Silver-Gold Acquisition and Exploration Strategy in New INN CEO Insights Interview

Triumph Gold’s Executive Chairman Discusses Utah Silver-Gold Acquisition and Exploration Strategy in New INN CEO Insights Interview

July 9, 2025
Quimbaya Gold

Quimbaya Gold

July 9, 2025
Juggernaut Closes $1,100,000 from Institutions and Accredited Investors

Juggernaut Closes $1,100,000 from Institutions and Accredited Investors

July 9, 2025
High Grade Cu-Au at Surface Delivers New Targets at Mankayan

High Grade Cu-Au at Surface Delivers New Targets at Mankayan

July 9, 2025
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

Copyright © 2025 revenueagenda.com | All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Investing
  • Latest News
  • Editor’s Pick
  • Economy

Copyright © 2025 revenueagenda.com | All Rights Reserved